Most Marriage Books Hurt Marriages

Most Marriage Books Hurt Marriages

During my thirty six years of married life, I have read many marriage books. Even when we had a difficult marriage, I would be searching and reading for answers to our marriage problems. Now, I understand clearly why most marriage books didn’t help me.

There’s one I’m reading now and it is written by a woman but she writes to men, too. She explains a wife’s role and then a husband’s role in marriage. I am often told that I need to teach men to love their wives as Christ loves the Church. There’s a problem with this method that I have found.

In this book I am reading, she explains that in a marriage there should be at least nine encouraging words from each other before speaking any type of correction, exhortation, or rebuke. This made me ponder and I was thinking that I needed to inform Ken that he must give me nine encouraging words before any type of correction. Yes, I was going to tell him because so-and-so said this was how a good marriage worked!

I didn’t discuss it right away with him, thankfully, but began pondering it. What if I tell him this plan and he then only gives me three encouraging words and then corrects me. Ooppss! I then tell him that he was wrong for doing this and needed to give me six more encouraging words before he corrected me. Guess what? I have become the leader in our marriage instead of him. I have decided to make up the rules instead of him. It doesn’t work. I tried this for 23 years. Besides, I would rather he give me encouraging words because he wants to give them to me and not because it’s expected of him.

If I were to teach men to treat their wives as the weaker vessel, then guess who would decide what that looked like? Does this mean he has to take care of the children and clean the house every night when he gets home to give her a break? How about the husband loving her as Christ loved the Church? Does this mean she gets to do whatever she wants and he is to support her in it?

Then there are questions a couple is supposed to ask each other when they’re in an argument: 1. Repeat what the spouse said to make sure you understand; 2. Look in their eyes and see the emotions behind what they are saying; 3. Talk and pray until a compromise is reached, etc. What about all of the Bible verses that teach us to not argue and fight, but pursue peace with all men? How about the fact that the husband is the head over the wife and she is to be subject to him in everything? These are usually not mentioned in marriage books.

God instructs wives to win their husbands “without the word” for a reason. I don’t know any woman who has changed her husband by continually correcting him, nagging him, or even simply speaking to him about his sins/faults. It’s not our job to change our husbands. The more expectations we put upon them, the worse our marriage will become.

If your husband does have a sin, fault, or bad habit that you want to confront him about, make sure that you have learned to not have any contempt, bitterness, or anger towards him first. Pull that log out of your own eye before approaching your husband. Learn to love him, be kind, patient, warm, and affectionate towards him. After he knows that you truly do love him and want the best for him, then make a gentle appeal to him once, then leave it with the Lord to convict and change him.

It’s not my place to teach women how their husbands should act since it becomes a stumbling block to a better marriage for most women, plus I am not instructed to teach men in the Word. Husbands have the choice how to act and if your husband does not obey the word, then obey 1 Peter 3:1-6. There’s no better prescription for you in your behavior towards your husband. We are to live in subjection to them (not trying to change them) with godly behavior  and without the word (without preaching or nagging) which means having meek and quiet spirits. The less expectations and “rules” you place upon your marriage, the better it will become.

By living in submission to him, showing him respect, kindness, warmth, and affection, you will have a much better chance of having a great marriage. This will draw your husband towards you instead of pushing him away. Forget the suggestions of what he’s supposed to do and instead focus upon what you’re supposed to do. Read marriage books that only address your part in the marriage and learn from them. Plus, most marriage books write nothing about a wife being subject to her husband in everything and obedient to him. Find ones that teach these important principles and ask the Lord to change you into the wife that He has created you to be.

Wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands, as unto the Lord. For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church: and he is the saviour of the body. Therefore as the church is subject unto Christ, so let the wives be to their own husbands in every thing.
Ephesians 5:22-24

22 thoughts on “Most Marriage Books Hurt Marriages

  1. Very well said. But I would add most books speak only of a husbands love and never approach the aspect of respect from a wife either. The book Love and respect was an amazing book, that speaks about racha part in that equation. We can’t expect our husbands to act better or love us more like we want, if we don’t show the respect due them and their position as head of the home! Great post!

  2. Thanks, I needed this today! I have had several issues lately with my husband that have really been bothering me, and it is SO tempting to fall into the “continually nagging, continual negativity” mode. Thank you so much for your good “mention it gently once and then pray” reminder.

  3. Amen! Not enough godly women are teaching other women these things, thank you!

  4. Amen to another great post! I agree, Lori, that most marriage books are watered down in the area of submission. Personally, my marriage did not improve until I stopped trying to change my husband. Asking the Lord for wisdom in our marriages always brings a humbling of ourselves first. Elizabeth Rice Handford , however, did write an excellent little book entitled, Me, Obey Him? It was one of the first books God directed me to find and read. ?

  5. Great post babes…! You are wonderful, a good friend, kind, caring, joyful, smart, godly, lovely person! (Now I forgot what I was criticizing you about :(.

  6. Hahaha Ken. Sometimes when my husband stuffs up, he buys me a small token of apology. It’s not something I expect or demand. Just his way of saying sorry, I goofed. Maybe some nice flowers would suffice? 😉 Or maybe even if you didn’t stuff up. Get her some love,y flowers anyway, just because. 🙂

  7. Good points Lori. Although if a marriage book suggested complimenting 9 times before correcting, I would of taken that as being my job, not his. But then I would of given up easily as I would of had a hard time trying to think up enough compliments. I have always hated the comment that my husband should be loving me as Christ loved the church. It always came across as a pathetic excuse to sin. What did Denny Kenaston call it? Sanctified manipulation?

  8. I find that most marriage books and marriage counselors as well add to the burden that wives feel by making them feel responsible for their husbands behavior, making them feel they have to take action and talk to them about their bad behavior, and worst of all, making them feel that their husband’s good behavior is a prerequisite for their own good behavior. That’s a tough load to bear and one that God doesn’t require us to, thankfully! There is such a freedom in trusting God and simply submitting to your husband.

  9. Pray and work on not “continually nagging, continual negativity” mode, too, since these aren’t pleasing to the Lord either, Diana. It’s so easy to see our husband’s sins and ignore our own. I know. I’ve definitely been guilty of this before.

  10. You’re welcome, Angela. Hopefully, other women will begin teaching these important things to women. It’s need desperately in the Church!

  11. I read that book a long time ago, Holly, and it was very good! Any book that is written just to the wives are a lot better and more effective than those who are written to both, in my opinion.

  12. That’s a good term for it because it’s exactly what it is. I just have found that I do better with no type of “games” but going to the Word and obeying what the Lord has called me to do.

  13. You’re right, EC! Life is a lot better and easier if we just focus upon living godly lives instead of trying to get our husbands to live “godly” lives according to our terms.

  14. I have only read 2 marriage books in my 15 years of being married, neither of them recently.
    One was “women are from mars and men are from Venus”. It was good in that it outlined the way men and women differ and helped me to understand my man better.

    The other one was “Secrets of Fascinating Womanhood” by David Coory. While it had a fair bit of nonsense in it, it gave practical examples of wifely submission towards her husband, which I found helpful. Knowing the principle of ‘submission’ and knowing how to put that principle into practice, are two different things, but it is important that we know both.

  15. focus on the word is the best thing in marriage. It approaches issues that the ancient people dealt with as well as issues that people face today.

    Keeping the word in the heart matters.

  16. Thanks, Lori! This just opened my eyes to how dangerous it can be getting marriage advice about the husbands role. I was listening to some On Christian radio and I had to talk myself out of wanting to confront my husband. This post helps me see much more clearly how damaging listening to this kind of thing can be.

  17. “In this book I am reading, she explains that in a marriage there should be at least nine encouraging words from each other before speaking any type of correction, exhortation, or rebuke. This made me ponder and I was thinking that I needed to inform Ken that he must give me nine encouraging words before any type of correction. Yes, I was going to tell him because so-and-so said this was how a good marriage worked!”

    This is why I say there is a difference between allowing a husband to lead, and following him. The wife will take it upon herself to direct his leadership. Following is merely submitting to his authority. No where in the bible does it say to allow Christ to lead us, however He says to follow him and Paul says it as well. Many of us who “get it fully” understand the minute differences and also see where the differences can be manipulated to justify why a husband needs to be directed.

    Pastors always tell wives to allow their husbands to lead, when the bible clearly says to submit. If anything about leading should be said, it should be when it says to take up your cross and follow, or when Jesus tells his disciples to follow. The young rich man said he would follow, but Jesus told him the birds have nests and the foxes have holes, but the Son of Man has no where to lie His head. This indicated the sacrifice and self denial it takes. Something the modern woman and christian woman has a very difficult time doing.

  18. My hubby and I enjoyed reading “Love & War” by John & Stasi Eldredge. It was an eye-opener for us, especially in terms of spiritual warfare and how the Devil is seeking to destroy marriage and family. I would recommend that one!

    Also, I am a big Dr. Laura fan, and her books “The Proper Care and Feeding of Husbands” and “The Proper Care and Feeding of Marriage” were both good common-sense reads. “Fit to be Tied” by Bill Hybels was good too.

  19. Yes yes yes! I’ve thought the same thing! If ever I have to think to myself, “let him lead,” I instead change the thought to, “I have no authority to ‘let’ or give him my permission to lead. He is the leader, I need to back off and get out of his way!”
    Wonderful wisdom and insight you’ve shared!

  20. Great article Lori! Good marriages don’t just happen by accident or by chance. A good marriage takes love, communication, intentional effort and commitment. The key to a good marriage is to regularly and purposefully invest in the good things that will help it grow into a deep, rich and fulfilling relationship. My wife and I wrote The 4P’s of Marriage to help couples understand why their marriage is PERSONAL, PRIVATE, PUBLIC, and PERMANENT. At the end of the day, a marriage is valued by what a husband and wife are willing to sacrifice for it. ? ?

    https://youtu.be/FQuMeYPKjl0

    Order your copy today by clicking on the following link: https://www.amazon.com/Four-Ps-Marriage-Personal-Permanent/dp/153325544X

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *